GRA Blogs

Articles by Matthew Gilligan

Busting Trust Myths

AUTHOR: Matthew Gilligan

POSTED: 21 August 2020

“Trust busting” is the term often used to describe instances where a court finds in favour of a claimant trying to access trust assets. Here, though, I do not want to talk about “trust busting”. Instead I want to bust some trust myths. There has been a lot of media coverage recently as a result of the new Trusts Act passing. Much of this coverage has suggested that trusts are now ineffective. This approach is regrettable and founded on a number of myths.

Myth One – Trusts don’t provide effective asset protection

While it is true there have been some notable relationship property cases where claimants successfully accessed trust property, you have to look “under the hood” of those cases to truly understand their impact. Often the trust deed or the trust admin (or both) are a shambles. Sometimes the court is seeking to redress a huge relationship property imbalance.

None of this means that a properly constituted and administered trust will not stand up to challenge. The bottom line is there is great value in having the insurance policy of a trust owning valuable assets.

Myth Two – There are no benefits in employing a trust

Trusts are often employed for estate planning purposes, which is a point often overlooked in the alarmist media commentary. Where assets are owned personally, they form part of your personal estate on death. Your personal estate can be subject to challenge. It can be subject to challenge by creditors, by an ex-spouse, by aggrieved family members or caregivers. On the other hand, where assets are held by a trust they are insulated from exposure to these types of claims.

While few people employ trusts for tax reasons, they can be effective in splitting income amongst beneficiaries to reach an efficient tax outcome.

Another point often made by media experts is that trusts provide no benefit when it comes to eligibility for the residential care subsidy. In my experience very few people set up a trust in the expectation it will help them qualify for the subsidy. That said, it generally places you in no worse position and if, for example, you receive an inheritance directly into a trust then that falls outside of your asset base as far as asset means testing is concerned for the residential care subsidy.

Myth Three – Beneficiary demands

One of the most notable aspects of the new law is a default requirement to contact beneficiaries of the trust and advise them of their standing as a beneficiary. From there, beneficiaries can seek information from trustees. However, they do not have a right to demand distributions from the trust. Furthermore, there can be reasons for trustees to not disclose information to beneficiaries. For example, if there is an expectation that disclosure will have a negative impact on the beneficiary or relationships within the family, trustees can elect not to make such disclosure.

While it is true that new rules are designed to make trustees more accountable to beneficiaries – which is as things should be – they do give scope for trustees to take into consideration a wide range of factors before deciding what information will be disclosed and to whom.

Myth Four – Onerous new law

While the new law includes some new duties, such as this default duty to contact beneficiaries and a duty to retain trust information, for the most part these are actions that a prudent trustee should be undertaking anyway. If anything, complying with the Act will ensure that trusts are more robust moving forward, enforcing good practice by trustees.

There are also positive aspects of the new law including some flexibility to alter aspects of the deed, in circumstances where previously you may have had to go to court to be able to do this. The maximum lifespan of a trust can also potentially be extended.

Conclusion

In summary, we still see significant value in employing trusts as part of a robust asset protection and estate planning structure. I find much of the media commentary to be alarmist and skin deep, ignoring many of the advantageous aspects of accumulating your hard earned capital in trust ownership over time.

GRA director, John Rowe, recently ran a webinar on the new trust rules, which you can view here if you would like to know more: https://www.gra.co.nz/resources/seminar-downloads

Request a Meeting

Matthew Gilligan
Director

09 522-7955

mg@gra.co.nz

© Gilligan Rowe & Associates LP

Did you like this article? Subscribe to our newsletter to receive tips, updates and useful information to help you protect your assets and grow your net worth. We're expert accountants providing expert advice to clients in NZ and around the world.

Disclaimer: This article is intended to provide only a summary of the issues associated with the topics covered. It does not purport to be comprehensive nor to provide specific advice. No person should act in reliance on any statement contained within this article without first obtaining specific professional advice. If you require any further information or advice on any matter covered within this article, please contact the author.

Comments

Testimonials

Just wanted to pass on how incredibly impressed I was with Quade Fraser, I have some complicated aspects to my personal situation and was looking at the a purchase of a property while needing to consider multiple individuals, a company and with my contracting and GST considerations.
I asked the consultant multiple questions over our meeting and he was able to calmly and articulately answer everything and give me cause to think about a whole lot of areas I would not have even thought of including; bright line, GST, mixed-use assets, trust structures (considering children beneficiaries), utilising a company structure etc. The bottom line is, I have a much better idea on what we need to do to structure my affairs in the most beneficial way for my family over the long-term.
Very knowledgeable, professional and with a great manner too. I got a huge amount of value out of the meeting.

- Kate, June 2023

We can help

Here's how

Investing in residential property?

Put this at the top of your reading list.

If you're investing in residential property, seeking to maximise your ability to succeed and minimise risk, then this is a 'must read'.

Matthew Gilligan provides a fresh look at residential property investment from an experienced investor’s viewpoint. Written in easy to understand language and including many case studies, Matthew explains the ins and outs of successful property investment.